Life Insurance Agent at desk in front of computer talking to leads on phone

Quality or Quantity: Which is Best for Insurance Agents Leads?

As an insurance agent, the choice to focus on lead quality or quantity can greatly impact your business. Both ways have their pros and cons. Understanding them can help you choose well. That way, you can pick what fits your goals. This article explores the pros and cons of choosing quality over quantity in buying leads. It uses real-world examples to illustrate each approach.

Quality Leads: The Focus on Higher Conversion Rates


  1. Higher Conversion Rates: Good leads come from people who have shown a real interest in buying insurance. This means they’re more likely to convert into paying clients. For instance, an agent buys a smaller batch of high-quality leads. They may find that many of these leads turn into customers. This raises their total sales production.

  2. Better Client Relationships: When dealing with quality leads, agents can take the time to build stronger relationships. This personalized approach can lead to higher client satisfaction and loyalty. For example, an agent who takes time to understand a lead’s needs and tailors their pitch is more likely to secure a long-term client.

  3. Cost Efficiency: While quality leads may cost more upfront, the higher conversion rates can make them more cost-effective in the long run. An agent spends $100 per quality lead. They might convert 50% of these leads. Cheaper leads might only convert at 10%. This makes the cost per acquisition lower with quality leads.


  1. Higher Initial Cost: Quality leads are often more expensive. This can be a significant investment for agents, especially those with limited budgets. For example, an agent might hesitate to spend $1,000 on ten leads if there’s no guarantee of conversion.

  2. Limited Volume: The availability of high-quality leads can be limited. This can restrict the agent’s ability to scale their business quickly. An agent relying solely on quality leads might struggle to reach broader market segments.

Quantity Leads: The Broad Approach


  1. Larger Reach: Purchasing a large quantity of leads allows agents to reach a broader audience. This can be particularly useful for new agents looking to build a client base quickly. For instance, an agent might buy 1,000 leads and send out a general marketing message, hoping to capture the interest of a larger group.

  2. Lower Cost per Lead: Quantity leads are usually cheaper per lead, making them more accessible for agents with smaller budgets. An agent might find it more manageable to spend $1,000 on 1,000 leads, even if the conversion rate is lower.

  3. Market Testing: With more leads, agents can test marketing strategies and messages. They can see what resonates best with potential clients. This can be invaluable for refining sales techniques and marketing approaches.


  1. Lower Conversion Rates: Quantity leads often come with lower conversion rates. They include people who may not have a strong interest in insurance. For example, an agent might find that only 5% of a large batch of leads show any interest, resulting in more effort for fewer sales.

  2. Time-Consuming: Managing and following up with a large number of leads can be time-consuming. Agents might spend significant time on unqualified leads, reducing overall efficiency. An agent might be overwhelmed with the volume of required follow-ups. This takes time from high-potential clients.

  3. Potential for Higher Drop-Off: With a broad approach, there’s a higher chance of leads losing interest or moving on before the agent can make contact. This can be frustrating and lead to wasted resources.

Real-World Examples

Example 1 – The Quality Approach: Sarah, an experienced insurance agent, decided to focus on quality leads. She invested in a smaller, more expensive batch of leads from a reputable provider. She dedicated time to each lead. She understood their needs and provided tailored solutions. This effort led to a 50% conversion rate. Her initial investment was high. But, the loyal client base it brought generated many referrals. This proved that her approach was cost-effective.

Example 2 – The Quantity Approach: John, a new insurance agent, opted for the quantity approach to quickly build his client base. He purchased a large volume of inexpensive leads. Although his conversion rate was only 5%, he managed to secure enough clients to establish his business. Over time, he refined his sales pitch and improved his conversion rate. But, he also had high attrition and spent much time on follow-ups.

Conclusion: Finding the Right Balance

In the end, the choice is between quality and quantity. It depends on your business goals, budget, and sales strategy. This approach is for agents who want to build deep, lasting client relationships. They are willing to invest more upfront. Focusing on quality leads can be a benefit. On the other hand, agents aiming to quickly expand their client base may prefer to handle more leads.

Many successful agents find a balance between the two. They start with a broad approach to build their base. Then, they gradually shift to quality leads as their business grows. You can understand the pros and cons of each method. You can do this by using real-world examples. Then, you can make an informed decision. This decision will align with your goals and maximize your success. The market for insurance is very competitive.

Agent Advantage is committed to staying current with industry trends and insights. We believe that by providing agents with well-researched, actionable information, we can contribute to the success of both individual agents and the industry as a whole. As Agent Advantage continues to shape the narrative of life insurance lead generation, we remain dedicated to supporting agents on their journey to success through the power of our resources.

Visit to learn more >>

Share with your network:

Download our FREE “Secrets Only Top-Performing Agents Know” eBook: